How to Find a Real Estate Agent With Experience Selling Homes Like Yours

Quick Answer

How do you know an agent has experience with homes like yours? Ask for recent examples of the same home type, price range or problem, and what the agent did differently on each. Specific stories beat general claims.

A condo with HOA special assessments, a mid-century house with a few quirks and a fixer all sell differently. The buyers are different, the financing is different and the pricing logic is different. So when you interview a listing agent, the question to ask is not how long they have been doing this. It is whether they have handled a home like yours.

This page is one of nine questions in my guide to choosing a listing agent. It covers experience with homes like yours: what to ask, what a good answer sounds like and how I answer it. For current conditions, the Seattle real estate market update is the page I keep current.

Why Home Type Changes the Plan

Every type of home has its own sale. A condo buyer reads the HOA paperwork as closely as the listing. A buyer of a house needing repairs is thinking about financing before they think about the kitchen. A townhome buyer compares monthly costs against a single-family home down the street. An agent who has seen those conversations before knows what to prepare, what to disclose and how to answer the hard questions.

The result is a stronger listing: the right photos, the right paperwork ready before the first showing and a price that reflects how those buyers think. Agents who have not handled the same situation can still do well, but they will be learning on your sale.

Four Examples From My Own Listings

Here are four situations I have worked through, so you can see what a specific answer sounds like. Ask any agent for the same level of detail.

An Edmonds Condo With HOA Special Assessments

Buyers worry when an association has a special assessment, because it changes their monthly cost and sometimes their loan. The work is to understand the assessment, explain what it covers and what it means for the buyer, and price the condo with that in view.

A Green Lake Townhome With HOA Complications

Townhomes can carry shared maintenance and ownership questions that a buyer will not find in the listing. The sale went better because the questions were identified early, instead of surfacing in the middle of a negotiation.

A Shoreline Bungalow That Sold in Two Days

Some homes sell fast, and the work is making sure the first days count: preparation, photos, a clear price and a launch plan that puts the home in front of buyers right away. The same plan applies to every home, but a bungalow in Shoreline has its own buyers, and knowing them shapes the pricing and the timing.

A Rainier Beach House and a Financing Problem

For a house in Rainier Beach, we compared a conventional loan with a rehab loan and fixed a shower leak so buyers could use conventional financing. The repair opened the home to more buyers. Choices like that come from knowing how lenders and buyers react to a specific condition, and the decision stays with the seller, who gets real information to make it.

Questions to Ask About Experience

  • Which recent listings were most like mine, and what happened?
  • What problems came up on those sales, and how did you solve them?
  • What do buyers in my neighborhood and price range look for?
  • Which lenders, inspectors, contractors and stagers do you call when a home has a specific issue?
  • What would you recommend I fix before listing, and what would you leave alone?
  • Can I speak with a past client who sold a home like mine?

Listen for names of places, steps in a process and results you can verify. An answer like “I have sold a lot of condos” is a start. An answer that explains what happened with one of them is better.

A Network of Trusted Resources

Selling a home involves lenders, inspectors, stagers, contractors, title officers and attorneys. The agent does not do each of those jobs, but a strong agent knows who does them well and can get them on the phone. When a problem comes up, the right call in the first hour can save the sale.

Ask each agent who they would call for your situation, and how quickly they can get a quote or an opinion. The names matter less than whether the agent has an answer. I work as a solo agent, so these relationships are mine: I personally advise on your sale, I negotiate and I stay through closing. Staff help with video, postcards and ads, and vendors handle photography, cleaning and title reports.

Experience That Is Honest About Its Limits

The best agents tell you when a situation is outside their experience, and who they would bring in. If a home has an unusual issue, such as an old oil tank, a permit question or an unusual zoning situation, the plan should name the specialist. An agent who says they have seen everything deserves a follow-up question.

The advice you want sounds like this: when to wait, when to fix and when to walk away. I put the numbers behind that advice in the market update and in my seller net proceeds calculator, so you can see what a sale would net before you decide.

What to Bring to the Interview

Give each agent the same information so you can compare their answers fairly: the age and size of the home, any known problems, recent repairs, the HOA documents if there are any, and what you need from the sale, such as a closing date or a minimum net. The more specific you are, the more specific the agent has to be.

Then ask the agent to walk you through how they would sell your home, step by step, and which parts they expect to be difficult. A good answer names the hard parts. If every part sounds easy, the agent may not have thought it through, or may not have seen it before.

When Two Agents Both Say Yes

If two agents both claim experience with homes like yours, compare the details. Which one gave you a story with a beginning, a problem and an outcome? Which one asked you questions about your home before answering? Which one told you something you had not considered? Experience shows up as questions and specifics. Use your notes from every interview to choose, and take a day before you sign.

How This Fits With the Other Eight Questions

Experience is one factor. Marketing, communication, time, negotiation, pricing, fees and contract terms matter just as much. The full guide to choosing a listing agent puts all nine side by side, and these pages go deeper:

For a look at how I work, see my Seattle real estate agent page. For preparation, maintenance realities by home type explains what buyers notice in each kind of home, and selling your home in Seattle from inspection to closing walks through the process after you accept an offer. If you want a broader overview, read selling your house made easy.

Check the License

Whatever home you are selling, confirm that your agent holds an active license using the Department of Licensing license lookup, read the duties a listing agent owes you in chapter 18.86 of the Revised Code of Washington and find consumer information on the real estate brokers page.

If you would like to talk through your home and which parts of the sale need extra attention, book a free 15-minute call. No pressure and no obligation. You can also request a free home value report or call or text me at (206) 245-8813.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many homes like mine should my agent have sold?

There is no magic number. Ask for recent examples that match your home’s type, age, price range and any special issue, and ask what the agent did on each one.

Does an agent need to specialize in my neighborhood?

Local knowledge helps, because pricing and buyers differ block by block. Ask what the agent has sold or worked on near you and what buyers there care about.

What if my home has a problem, like an HOA issue or a repair?

Ask for a story about a similar problem and how it was solved. The answer shows whether the agent has a plan or is guessing.

Should I ask for references?

Yes. Past clients with a similar home can tell you how the agent handled problems, which a listing presentation will not.

Is a bigger team better for a unique home?

Not necessarily. Ask who you will work with day to day and who makes the pricing and negotiation decisions on your home.

Emily Cressey

Emily Cressey is a licensed NWMLS real estate broker and team lead with HomePro Associates at Keller Williams Greater Seattle. In real estate since 2002, starting as an investor, she has lived in Lake Forest Park for over two decades. Emily helps buyers, sellers, and investors across Shoreline, Kenmore, Bothell, Edmonds, Lynnwood, Mountlake Terrace, and Brier, with a focus on investment, rental, and estate properties. She is a FastExpert Top 15 Agent in Kenmore for 2025 and 2026.

Connect With Us!

If you're looking to buy or sell a property connect with us today!

How Can We Help You?

We would love to hear from you! Please fill out this form and we will get in touch with you shortly.

    (check all that apply)
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.